Since you guys are planning a grading workshop and we've been dicussing how we grade books I thought I'd put this up for discussion. This was one of the first keys I bought before I knew more about grading and I eagerly sent it in to CGC. I've since cracked it out. It looks nice but it has a few issues:
1) There's a small tear at the top staple by spidermans right foot.
2) There's a large ding on top that goes through the entire book (looks like it had a paper clip there). It's hard to see but if you look at the back cover you can see how it goes through the book.
3) There's a thumb ding on the right side (goes through the entire book).
4) The BC has a small piece missing on the lower corner and small tear on the side.
That's the major stuff.
Oh, no missing pages, cover and centerfold is attached.
I'd like to see grades from 1 - 10 and I will post the actual CGC grade later. There's a few additional pics after the FC & BC scans.