Warning Warning All American #16 CGC VF 8.0 Seller

ComicCollectors · **Posted:** Jan 09, 2008 6:57 PM

Just received a phone call at 6:04 pm est from a seller claiming to have and All American Comics #16 VF 8.0. He claimed he had offered it to a few dealers, and would accept no less than $15,000. After first asking him if it was certified he said no. Then when I asked him if it was unrestored, he said he had sent it to someone about a year ago and had the paperwork to prove it was unrestored. Knowing full well there are no certified VF copies of this book, I proceeded to ask him if he would send me a scan of the book. I then asked him who assessed the book a VF 8.0 and claimed it unrestored. He said CGC, but the page quality was missing. I asked how is that possible if the book was still in the holder? Then we were mysteriously disconnected.

CALLER ID Name & Phone Number: Misty Corder (231) 834-1318

Someone should post this on the CGC Forum.

Mr. Zipper · **Joined:** Apr 25, 2007 2:21 AM **Posts:** 6033

Marnin Rosenberg wrote:

Someone should post this on the CGC Forum.

How about you?

:baiting:

ComicCollectors · **Posted:** Jan 10, 2008 10:37 AM

Steve Zarelli wrote:

Marnin Rosenberg wrote:

Someone should post this on the CGC Forum.

How about you?

:baiting:

Transplant · **Joined:** Nov 08, 2007 6:09 PM **Posts:** 130

Marnin:

Would you mind if I posted this there?

ComicCollectors · **Posted:** Jan 16, 2008 11:05 AM

Mike Strahan wrote:

Marnin:

Would you mind if I posted this there?

Not at all Mike. In fact, the guy tried me back 2 days later, and when I saw the same name on my caller ID, I simply didn't pick-up, and no message was left.

For all I know, by now, someone may have got a nice restored copy, but I never follow-up with anyone I suspect is telling a tale. I'm not that hungry.

Publications

Informative

Historical

Warning Warning All American #16 CGC VF 8.0 Seller

Who is online